Monday, January 21, 2008

Democracy and politics

The discussion about democracy means the search of a political institution and the arrangements which are unbreakably connected with the creation of a human type that would correspond to these arrangements. However the genuine politics results from an uncommon and fragile social-historical construction. What always are present in a society, they are the political principles, that is to say the unambiguous and tacit and sometimes almost insignificant dimensions, which have to do with the power. Here it is the institutionalized rule or rules that could address commands with sanctions and that at least should always include expressly this, what we may call governmental power and juridical power.

There is not any person outside of the society, and does not exist any human individual as an asocial or and an outer-social or pre-social substance, neither as reality nor as a constituted imagination. For example, we cannot figure out an individual without a language and each language is obligatorily a social construction and an institution. It is not possible to observe this construction and this institution critically; it is neither a release of a pre-determined cooperation between the individuals nor an addition of inter-material networks. In order to admit that the inter-subjectivity is existent should firstly be human subjects with the possibility to communicate between them. In other words, there must be already socialized persons who have already a language that they could not produce as individuals by their selves and who should receive this by way of their socialization. We could, by the same reasoning, search and find thousand other sides of this that we call an individual.

The modern political philosophies as well as most of these that are offered as the economic science are based on the incoherent fictitious construct of an individual substance, the essential characteristics of which are determined with clarity outside or before the existence of each society. Upon this foolery are necessarily sponsored, so much the idea of democracy as a simple process, as well as the modern pseudo-individualism. Outside the society the person is simply neither a beast nor a god, he cannot exist for the most part neither materially nor mentally. The hopeful and dreadful monster, who is the newborn person, is radically unprotected in front of life and it should be humanized, that is to say, this humanisation is its socialization and the work of the society that mediates and this is realized by its direct environment.

The quintessence of the society is the institution in conjunction with the social imaginary significances, by means of which this institution is embodied and constructed within the social reality. Precisely these significances give an imaginary meaning to the life, that is, to the activities and to the choices and to the death of persons, as well as to the world that is constructed and within which the persons should live and die. And all this is done in the profound significance of the word, that is to say, with the implication of a spontaneous construction of the humanity, and devoid of any motives.

The real polarization is not at hand between the individual and the society, but between psyche and society, because the individual is of course the society, it is something as a fragment and at the same time a micrograph or better said something as hologram of the social world. The psyche should be brought under control as far as possible and should accept a reality that in the beginning, and from some point of view until its end, is radically heterogeneous and strange. This reality and its acceptance are the job of the radical imagination. The Greeks knew this, but the modern ones suspended this because of the religion and belief.

The institution, in addition to the imaginary significances that conveys, cannot exist otherwise, but only if it is self maintained and if it is capable to survive. The tautology of Darwin finds also here a fertile field of application. It is self maintained among other things by means of the power, and this power exists as a principle as an implicit and always radical sublayer of power. When we are born in Greece in 1922 or in Kurdistan now, this fact was not decided by our selves, and however this simple detail will give a ruling to the most essential part of our life, that is, to our language and our religion, to the 99% of our thought and to the reasons for which we want to live and of the why we accept, or we do not accept, to die. This is something much more and something perfectly different from our simple presence in a world that we have not selected. This world is not one world or simply a world, social-historically it is a world formed by its institution and which contains countless fragments of the previous history in a way that cannot be described.

As soon as the human subject is born, it will be found within a social field and it will conditioned by the instituting collective imaginary and by the instituted society as well as by the history, that is to say, by the provisional termination that constitutes the particular institution. In principle, the society cannot do others as to produce social individuals, who conform to this society and who reproduce from their side the same individuals again. Even if someone is given birth in a conflicting society, the field of conflicts and its objects, as well as the options, are given beforehand. Also, if someone is to become a philosopher, the starting line of his reflection will be the specific history of the particular philosophy, and certainly it will be not another one. We will find our selves at this point far beyond of all kinds of intention, of willpower, of manoeuvres, of conspiracy, or far beyond of provision of any determining institution, law, group or orderliness.

Next to, or above of this implicit sublayer of power, an explicit power has existed and will always exist and enact by its specific bodies and operations, such as the legal sanctions from the positive right that this power can impose. The necessity of existence of this power results from four elements at least:
· The pre-social world as such always threatens the meaning that the society has established,
· The psyche of the individual persons is neither socialized nor could ever be socialized and be rendered absolutely conformal to those requirements, which are asked by the institutions,
· There are other societies that endanger the meaning that has been established by the specific society
· The society contains always within its institution and within its imaginary significances a tendency to the future, and the future excludes beforehand the extensive coding or mechanization of the decisions that should be taken.

From the above elements may be concluded the necessity of expressly legislated principles that might take decisions on sanctions about this what should be and what should not be, that is to say, which might legislate, execute, judge the differences, and govern. The two first from the above operations could be found hidden in the ethical social conventions, and thus this has occurred in the most archaic societies, the two next cannot be found at that time. Most important of all, this explicit power is the enacted guarantor of the monopoly of the legitimate significances within each society.

Politics includes all that concern this explicit power, such as the ways of access to this, the advisable way of its management, etc.

This way of power establishment covers almost the entirety of the human history. The heteronomous societies are also which as expected construct their own institutions and meanings, but they may conceal its self institution attributing this to a source outside of the society or exterior to the real activity of the undeniably real community in each case. They attribute this to the ancestors, to the heroes, to the gods, to the laws of history or to the market. In the heteronomous societies the institution of the society happens under circumstances of confinement of the meaning. All the questions, which may be constructed by each society, might find their answer within the framework of its imaginary significances, while the questions that cannot be constructed are not prohibited, but are blocked for the members of society mentally and psychically.

As far as we know, this situation has been inverted only two times in the history. Once in ancient Greece and once more in Western Europe and we are the beneficiaries of this capsizing, this is a fact that allows us to talk as we talk. The turn here is expressed by the construction of politics and of philosophy, of thinking.
· Politics means the challenge of the prearranged institutions.
· Philosophy means the challenge of the collectively acceptable interpretations and of the idols of the tribe.

In these two societies the confinement of the meaning has been ruptured or at least it tends to be fractured. The rupture, as well as the activity of continuous reflection that accompanies it, involve the rejection of all source of meaning that does not arise from the life activity of the individuals. It consequently involves potentially the rejection of each authority that would not reasonably justify the validity of its statements. From all this, it may almost automatically be concluded:
· There obligation of all individuals to justify their actions and their sayings,
· The rejection of the gap of distinctions or differentiations, that is to say, of hierarchies in the relationships between the individuals, and consequently also the contestation of each power that emanates from them,
· The appearance of the question of the good or of the enhanced institutions, since they depend of the conscious and explicit activity of the community, consequently also and the appearance of the question of fairness.

It is obvious that these consequences direct us to see politics as an occupation that concerns all the members of a given community and presuppose the equality of all as well as the desire that the equal opportunities will be political reality. We can consequently define politics as an explicit and transparent activity that concerns the establishment of the institutions, and democracy as the establishment of the explicit and transparent self-institution, as far as possible, of those social institutions which depend on the communal activity beyond doubt.

It does not need to add that the self-institution and the autonomy are dynamics that do not move towards a standstill or status quo, and that do not search for a perfect society, which is an expression without meaning, but for a freer and more reasonable society, as far as possible. In this dynamics we always refer when we talk about the interpretation for the autonomy, which should establish a democratic autonomous society, if the respective society is instituted as such.

At this point emerges a question that has been posed in fact in the past.
· Why do we desire and also why are we obligated to desire a democratic government?

We simply point out the fact that we should live in an establishment where all the questions can be posed, and this is the democratic government precisely. Therefore it may be immediately concluded that an institution defines the democracy as an institution, if all the questions can be posed there and where the position and status of an individual are not prearranged or are guaranteed beforehand.

No comments: