Space problems: Here, There, Somewhere
The most elementary orientation in the world, as it takes place on the stage of the sensorial confidence and the direct perception, depends on the immediate presence and proximity. It is a subjective orientation, which here emerges from the threefold starting point of the ‘I’ – Here - Now. We have to be problem-free oriented in the world and to be able to agree on all concerned this, because we all continue from this initial point, the ‘I’ – Here - Now.
These are not nominal words by which we represent things or facts. These are showing expressions by which as of our place could be shown all other persons, the time points and the positions. It should be directly clear, and therefore we should not interpret into these words any philosophical speculations also.
· But are the things so simple concerning the indication?
By the starting point of the distinct Here are indicated in the language all other positions, and by the starting point of Now are indicated all other time points.
· However, how could we have in the indicated field and as of this always subjective perception a common experience of the world, as well as of its social, spatial and temporal dimensions?
That is henceforth the question, which already worried very deeply a number of philosophers.
· What is then the Here?
· What is the Now?
· What is the “I”?
But on the one hand, if we want to grasp directly this ‘I’, this Now, and this Here, it always disappears. This here is for example the tree. We turn ourselves, and then this truth disappears and is reversed into its opposite one. The Here is not a tree, but it is rather a house. We are thus already at the beginning in a wrong world.
· And on the other hand, how can we emerge as of this momentary immediacy in the world which cannot be showed up, but it can only be thought or said?
· Isn't there a gap between our felt ‘I’- Now- Here and our experienced world, even an abyss, which cannot easily be skipped over?
It is a typical problem and we however need somewhat more acrobatics of the thinking, than this we could ever dream. Our philosophical head begins to work and starts on to produce thoughts. Let’s regard first their spatial aspect, and we are thus at a definite place, which is indicated to us by the showing the position Here. Thus we do not have any problems with this. In the opposite, only here we feel safe. We persistently try to keep constant this starting point in the space, and we distrustfully announce our fundamental doubts to our movement far of this place. The unfamiliar world of one indefinite foreign country and of one elsewhere, are one Here not familiar to us and which threatens to lead us to a loss of orientation, which have we to avoid. So far must become problematic for us the significance of all those words, which refer to one distant Not-Here.
If the orientation is fixed on the direct Here, then all things can only be trusted at this place. Therefore their naked presence at any indefinite space module and their somewhere being is for us not quite easy to be seized. The indefinite use of local adverbs had to confuse us. The search for the shifted eyeglasses which are not at their confident place leads to the wrong-headed question about the sense of somewhere.
The fixingness on the own Here lets become unclear the perspective of the other one. The use of showing words, in which the assumption of a external point of view is required, leads to disorientation, the transport of a bass drum to another place brings insurmountable difficulties with itself, because it cannot be clarified, who and on which side should seize, Here or There. The order which someone wants to create annoyed about the constant back and forth, finally fails not least because of the misunderstanding of the position showing words.
Which generally functions without thought acrobatics, makes excessive demands of that which can understand the local adverbs by showing only from the always own point of view. This stubborn holding to the subjective orienting point leads to the fact that also the identity of the same object is questioned, if it appears in multiple viewpoints.
The lack of distance of the spatial Here is radicalized in the lack of understanding contrary to everything, which is elsewhere. The other place becomes without any structure. It is not any longer subject the arrangements, which make an orientation possible in the Here. Successively, the absurd play uses the lack of dimension of the unfamiliar place, which is not subject to the orders of the expressive Here. The presence a person is immediately possible, since its absence is not to be accommodated now here into the coordinate system of the starting point of the Self. This often leads to the consequence that the hero is authorized to act only, if at all, in the close context of the spatial sureness. The space does not appear any more as place of a possible activity, if one does not know, what where happens elsewhere. This, now I know nothing, expresses a confusion, which expresses itself in the language as a sow-stupid gossip, in which the meaning contents of those indications of the language, which refer to the uncertainty at the unfamiliar place, and is only understood from the safe viewpoint of the concrete spatial Here.
Time problems: Now, Future, Past
Something comparable also is shown up by those time forms that exceed the now of the immediate moment. The consciousness emerges also not from the Now-Being and it is a completely immediate perception of the pure immediate presence. The use of the time adverbs is highly confusing, if they refer to a future time point which cannot be determined exactly.
The fact that the future event is not fully conditional, sure and foreseeable, provokes this persistent question about the exact time point, which must appear as very stupid in view of the possibility of future tolerance. The uncertainty of the Sometime may lead up to the distrust of the future events. Their Non-presence allows that the future may become problematic. The doubt can be eliminated only by the Now in its timeless interval. Only what we see is the only reliable reference point of the experience in the time.
The same uncertainty as opposed to what is not yet, exists as opposite to the past, which is not any more. The concentration on the Now permits that the Past disappears. It dissolves, either into a vague chaos, or it is completely forgotten. Therefore forgetfulness is a substantial characteristic of the constructed facts. It is not an individual psychopathologic event of the everyday life, which we can interpret, but characteristic of the personality. There is nothing which is not forgotten, such as places, names, the death of the woman and the own age for example.
The now fills out the perceptive consciousness in such a way that only little space remains for a structured memory. It explains the very stupid nonsense, when we represent historical events or inform about them. For the reason that history is now available over names still, if necessary, which still suggest a historical reference, however, the confident meaning of which is not any longer known. The historical memory is filled with meaningless names, which could be arranged at will in the verbal communication. The talking about historical facts is made possible only as puzzle without every relationship. The historical knowledge exists in the recourse to the heard facts, without that the real historical process plays a role here.
Talking about the past is insignificant for the ‘I’ in ‘Now’. Also the recourse to the borrowed authority gives no more meaning. As a foreign experience which extends beyond the Now, it does not have any requirement on authenticity. The bridge between present and past is broken off. Logically, by bringing this thought to an end, this will be a historical talking which consists of a series of naked misaligned pieces only.
The time appears as a steady ‘Now’. This has the consequence that the presence of time will be not experienced any more as an organized structure in the three dimensions of past, present and future. It becomes amorphous and unstructured. The in past is put out of the dynamic structuring of the time progress. This important inability to experience the presence of time appears also into a letter, which the man at home writes to his wife in cure, When you will write to me again, please write into the letter, what time is it. I do no idea, how am I in the time.
The depiction of the fore-played space and time consciousness was intended to clarify that if necessary the orientation is possible only in the showing field, which is formed around the starting point of the ‘I’ - Now - Here. Therefore all language forms must be also confusing, where it is exceeded the positive identification of what the fact is.
Nothing
The Here and Now is a thorough Positivism. This is there. The possibility of talking meaningfully about what it is not there, characterizes one of the deepest abysses of the language. We do not want to get involved in a linguistic usage, into which can be defined the Non-Being. As philosophical individuals we participate then in an unsolvable conflict within the philosophy, even if we should not have known it.
Because the problem, whether the Nothing does exist or not, belongs to the long-lasting phenomena of the history of the European philosophy. Our thinking corresponds completely to the doctrine of Being, which outlined 500 B.C. about the wise Parmenides from the under Italian Elea. Because he was this Thinker, who as the first had concluded in his great training poem about nature (Περί φύσεως) the thinking, which way is the only one that can lead to the knowledge of the truth. The Goddess of the truth had revealed this to him. There is only the way to it, which is the Being. Because so that somewhat is not the Being, it cannot either be perceived or shown.
· However, how does it work with this what is not Being?
For Parmenides was there only the meaningful alternative.
· Either it is there, or it is not there.
But, this solution results in only one open way to the Being.
· It is correct to say and to think that the Being is there; because only this can be there;
· The Nothing is not there. I said this to you; you have to shed light on this. But there is also the way of the deathly, but it is full of traps.
This ban saying could not remain without contradiction. Democritus of Abdera, the laughing philosopher, was one of the first supporters of the being of the Empty Space, because according to him the world could not consist only of the Being. Movement is an empiric reality and there is not a need to be proved.
· The primary causes of our universe for him are then the atoms and the empty space.
Thus, there is on the one hand the empty space, the Nothing (ουδέν), just as the atoms, the space-filling things, and these atoms do exist on the other hand, as well as the Empty Space between the atoms. We know surely today that the universe is full of radiation.
Thus the conflict was commenced between the Philosophers of the Being and of the Nothing, which is not decided yet. For us it is clear that there is not empty space in our universe at least, and that the philosophers of being unconditionally have our support.
· The Nothing is not there.
Because we cannot perceive, what is not there. We do not follow this way in the philosophical academy, but here in the existence.
The perceptible is this which is there. Something absent cannot be perceived. The denial, he is not there, seems to hang on as if it were a pendulum in the air.
· But, do we not say also, I have immediately seen that he is not there?
The fact that here it concerns a serious philosophical problem has demonstrated Jean Jean-Paul Sartre 1943 in its monumental work The Being and the Nothing. We know that thereby he was guided particularly by Martin Heidegger’s Metaphysics of Nothing, in which the immaterial, but annihilating force of the Nothing played the main role. Against the limited everyday experience, which does not reveal us the Non-Being, and against the scientific attentiveness on the actual and real, the frightening Nothing into which humans are exposed was confirmed by him. Sartre was inspired by Heidegger and had to be provoked as of Parmenides’ denial that we cannot see this which is not there.
We do not know, whether Sartre did take up from his experience the grammatical joke of the famous restaurant scene into The Being and the Nothing, but he gave to this a confusing turn. Sartre had explicitly arranged an appointment with Martin. But he came half an hour too late. Martin was always punctual to his appointments.
· Had he waited for Sartre?
We look around in the restaurant; we observe the guests and say,
· He is not there.
· Is here a direct knowledge of the Martin’s absence?
Martin would have answered with a Never! We cannot see the Martin’s presence yet. Sartre however had other eyes, even if he appeared thereby somewhat dizzy. Because he had expected to see Martin in the restaurant, his expectation obliges him to see Martin’s absence like a reality, which is an event, concerned the restaurant. Presently is the absence an objective fact, then he discovered this. As phantom appears the Non-Martin between Sartre and the reliable real things of the restaurant, which became insignificant, diminished and were done nothing, because Sartre has seen that his Martin was not there. That is, this Form, which emerges as the Nothing against the background of the restaurant, in such a manner that that the presented to the direct knowledge is no more that a flickering of Nothing, a Nothing of the background, whose insignificance calls for the emergence of the Form and demands that the Non-Form slides around on the surface of the background like a Nothing.
Which scared Sartre, could only be funny for Martin, because the Martin’s Non-Being was present and this Nothing does not affect the Being unpleasantly.
· Is Sartre’s philosophical seriousness not funny in this case?
In village bar the same happens much more joyfully than in Paris Restaurant. Both had been punctual arrived, but it was too dark in order to be able to see their selves immediately. That brought a first problem by itself. But, here at least the voice becomes then a reliable indication of Martin’s existence, even if Sartre cannot see him. However, it leads the two fast to the humorous problem, what is the matter with the sense of hearing, if we are noiseless.
· How does it happen now about the Nothing of the talking?
We cannot hear the Non-Talking at all.
Tuesday, December 4, 2007
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)